The blog

Witchy Christmas books to read when the nights get long

Some of us do not want a perfectly ordinary Christmas novel, as much as I love those too. We want frost on the window, a candle in a circle, a Yule log that is doing a little more than burning, and a story that believes midwinter is a door. If you have been searching for witchy Christmas books, here is a shelf I trust, with honest notes about which ones are cozy, which ones are spicier, and which ones are midwinter rather than tinsel.

I am not affiliated with these authors. I am a writer of short holiday stories who also reads with a blanket and a strong opinion about snow.

First, a classic that is funny on purpose

Hogfather by Terry Pratchett is the midwinter book I press into people’s hands when they want magic and do not want syrup. In Discworld, the Hogfather — their Father Christmas — has gone missing, and Death fills in, with a shopping mall, a sleigh, and a very literal approach to belief. It is a standalone enough story that you can read it without having finished the whole Discworld shelf, though the usual Pratchett warning applies: it is satire, it is kind, and it will sneak a serious idea past you while you are laughing. If your “witchy Christmas” is really a wish for magical Christmas, start here.

Midwinter, witches, and old magic

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis is a children’s book, and I will not pretend otherwise. I include it because so many adult readers still feel Christmas in it: the lamp-post in the snow, the long winter, the Turkish delight, the moment the season finally turns. If you are building a witchy Christmas stack for a household that reads at different ages, it still belongs at the bottom of the pile.

The Dark Is Rising by Susan Cooper is the one I think of as true midwinter magic. On the eve of his eleventh birthday, at the winter solstice, Will Stanton learns he is one of the Old Ones, and the twelve days of Christmas become a battle of Light and Dark in a snow-deep English landscape. It is often published for younger readers and it is more than rich enough for adults. It is not a romance, and it is not cozy in the teashop sense. It is the feeling of standing in a lane at dusk and realizing the year has a hinge.

The Winter Witch by Paula Brackston is a historical novel set in early nineteenth-century Wales, about Morgana, a mute young woman with uncontrolled magic, an arranged marriage, and a community ready to turn on what it does not understand. It is more hearth-and-mountain than wrapping paper, and I think of it as a winter witch book rather than a Christmas one. If you want your seasonal reading a little older, colder, and more folkloric, it fits.

Yule romances, with a heat check

The Wedding Witch by Erin Sterling, who also wrote The Ex Hex, is a proper Yuletide rom-com: a wedding at a grand Welsh estate, a ghost, a trip back to a mid-century Yule celebration, and two people who were not planning to fall in love beside the mistletoe. Sterling writes funny, witchy adult romance. This one has more heat than the closed-door stories I write, and I want you to know that before you settle in with cocoa and get a different kind of scene than you expected. If you want the Halloween cousin, The Ex Hex is the first in that witchy corner, and it is more October than December.

A Spell for Midwinter’s Heart by Morgan Lockhart is a holiday romance with a witch who has sworn off magic, a small-town winter festival in trouble, an estranged coven, and a childhood rival who will not stay out of the way. It is built for Yule: snow that has not fallen yet, lights that spark when they should not, and the question of whether you can go home again. If you want a contemporary witchy Christmas without going all the way back to a children’s classic, this is a sound place to start.

I also keep a longer list of winter fantasy romance for when you want snow and a slow-burn, and a list of clean paranormal romance for when you want the magic and not the open door.

What you can read tonight, and what is coming

I do not have a witchy Christmas novel on the shelf this week, and I will not invent one. I do have three clean Friendsgiving stories, which sit in the same season as the first snow and the first crowded table: The Extra Place Setting, Slightly on Fire, and The Missing Maple Pie. They are short enough to finish in an evening, and they are about the people we choose when the holiday does not go to plan.

New magical novellas are coming soon, including winter and holiday stories with witches, hidden worlds, and closed-door romance. I will add them here as soon as they are live, and I will be honest about which ones are Christmas, which ones are Yule, and which ones are simply cold and glittering.

If your December stack can hold one funny book, one folkloric book, and one romance, I would take Hogfather, The Dark Is Rising, and then either Lockhart or Sterling depending on how much heat you want beside the fire. That is a very good week of long nights.