The blog

Books like A Discovery of Witches

When you finish A Discovery of Witches, the hunger is very specific. You want another historian who is not quite ordinary. You want a library that is hiding something, a city where witches and vampires have been negotiating in quiet rooms for centuries, and a love story that takes itself seriously. A great many of us type the same phrase into the search box. Books like A Discovery of Witches.

I should say two things plainly. I am not affiliated with Deborah Harkness or with the authors below. And “like” is a loose word. Harkness’s All Souls books are grown-up hidden-world novels: Diana Bishop is a historian and a witch, Matthew Clairmont is a vampire with a long memory, and Oxford is only the first door. They are also adult romances. They include more mature intimate content than a closed-door story. If that is what you loved, I will point you toward books with a similar temperature. If you came for the libraries and the secret families and would rather the bedroom door stay shut, I will tell you which shelves are safer.

If you have not finished the All Souls books themselves — Shadow of Night, The Book of Life, and the later novels that follow Diana and Matthew’s family — start there. The best next book is sometimes the next book in the series you already love.

If what you loved was the scholarly hunt

The Historian by Elizabeth Kostova is the book I hand people who cannot stop thinking about the research. A scholar, a father’s papers, a trail of letters, and a search for Dracula that moves through libraries and archives across Europe. It is atmospheric and patient. It is not a romance-first novel, and it is not spicy. If the pleasure of A Discovery of Witches was opening a manuscript that should not have opened, this is the closest cousin I know.

The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane by Katherine Howe has a similar academic pulse. A Harvard graduate student inherits a house, finds a name in an old document, and is pulled back toward Salem and a hidden tradition of women’s knowledge. It is a historical mystery with witchcraft at its center, and it scratches the particular itch of a researcher who cannot leave a footnote alone.

Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke is longer, drier in the best way, and one of the great modern novels about English magic. Two magicians in the Napoleonic era restore practical magic to a country that had almost forgotten it. There are footnotes, rivalries, and a sense that history itself has been quietly rewritten. It is not a hidden-world romance, but if you loved the feeling that scholarship and spellwork might be the same craft, it belongs on this list.

If what you loved was a secret people living beside us

The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker sets two magical beings down in 1899 New York and lets them learn the city, and each other, at a human pace. It is richly researched, warm and melancholy by turns, and much more interested in work, friendship, and belonging than in a forbidden affair. The hidden world here is a neighborhood.

Practical Magic by Alice Hoffman is the witch-family novel a lot of All Souls readers reach for next, especially if they wanted sisters, aunts, and a house that remembers. It is contemporary, bittersweet, and more about the cost of being a woman with a gift than about vampires. Weyward by Emilia Hart braids three centuries of women who will not stay small, with witchcraft as inheritance and as survival. Both are worth your time. Neither is a copy of Harkness, and I will not pretend they are.

If what you loved was the atmosphere, and the love story bound up with magic

The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern is the recommendation I give when someone says they miss the mood more than the Congregation. A black-and-white circus, a contest, a slow devotion, and almost no explicit heat. I have written about it in books to read after Twilight and in clean paranormal romance, because it keeps turning up whenever a reader wants wonder with their longing.

A Darker Shade of Magic by V.E. Schwab is a book Harkness has recommended herself: four Londons, a magician who can walk between them, and historical fantasy with real momentum. It is an adventure first and a romance second, and it is a fine next step if you want more world and a little less archive.

A few titles I will not put on the same shelf without a warning

Outlander by Diana Gabaldon is another Harkness recommendation, and the time-travel and historical sweep will feel familiar to anyone who loved Shadow of Night. It is also a steamy adult romance, and it is not a story about witches and vampires. Go to it on purpose, not by accident.

The Witching Hour by Anne Rice is the other great American witch-dynasty novel, and it is darker and often more explicit than All Souls. Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo and Babel by R.F. Kuang will satisfy a hunger for elite schools and dangerous scholarship; they are also heavy books, and I talk about their content more honestly in magic academy books for adults.

A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas is often recommended alongside Harkness. It is a different genre temperature: romantasy, and especially later, much steamier. If you want the door to stay shut, look at clean paranormal romance instead, or at vampire romance without spice if the fangs were the point.

Short reads, and what I am writing

I write short, clean stories, not thousand-page hidden-world epics, and I will not relabel them to pretend otherwise. If you want a complete book tonight, The Extra Place Setting is a closed-door Friendsgiving romance, Slightly on Fire is a comedy, and The Missing Maple Pie is a cozy mystery. They are evening-length, and the door stays shut.

New magical novellas are coming soon: hidden worlds, slow-burn closed-door love, and stories short enough to finish in a night. They will not be All Souls, and I will not claim they are. They will be for readers who want the wonder and the tension, and a book that ends before midnight. I will link them here when they are live. Until then, Kostova or Howe will keep you in the archive, Wecker or Hoffman will keep you in a hidden street, and Morgenstern will keep the lamps lit.

The next manuscript is already waiting. It usually is.